“I can terminate you at any time” makes termination clause void

“I can terminate you at any time” makes termination clause void

Barry B. Fisher LL.B.

Time to read 2 minutes read
Calendar July 15, 2024

In Dufault v. The Corporation of the Township of Ignace, 2024 ONSC 1029, Justice Pierce reviewed the following without cause termination clause:

“The Township may at its sole discretion and without cause, terminate this Agreement and the Employee’s employment thereunder at any time upon giving to the Employee written notice as follows: 

(i) the Township will continue to pay the Employee’s base salary for a period of two (2) weeks per full year of service to a maximum payment of four (4) months or the period required by the Employment Standards Act, 2000 whichever is greater. This payment in lieu of notice will be made from the date of termination, payable in bi-weekly installments on the normal payroll day or on a lump sum basis at the discretion of the Township, subject at all times to the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, 2000. 

The judge found that this clause was illegal as it contravened the ESA in the following ways:

  1. Base Salary is different from Regular Wages as required by the ESA which can include commissions, bonuses and the like.
  2. Section 61(1) of the ESA requires that pay in lieu of notice be paid as a lump sum and not on an installment basis.
  3. By giving the Employer the sole discretion to terminate at any time , this breaches both section 53 (reinstatement after a protected leave ) as well as Section 74 (reprisal for exercising a right under the ESA).

My Comments:

This case now adds to the long list in the way which poorly drafted termination clauses can violate the ESA and render the entire termination provision unenforceable. Normally, this leads to a determination of reasonable notice; however, in this case because the Plaintiff was terminated partly into a fixed term contract (another huge mistake in drafting) she received compensation for the balance of the contract, which was 101 weeks or $157,071.

This case is under appeal.

Table of Contents

Compliance Made Easy®

Canada’s most trusted compliance software for quick and easy HR, payroll, and internal controls compliance and policy management.
Book a Demo

Related Posts

Imagen 1

Sleeping on the Job? What do you have to do to get fired in Canada, anyway?

Employees can be dismissed for cause, and therefore without notice or severance, when their misconduct or performance is so egregious that the employment relationship has been irreparably harmed. In assessing this issue, employers must adopt a contextual approach, which considers not only the misconduct in question, but the entirety of the employment relationship.

Rudner Law, Employment / HR Law & Mediation

Read more
Imagen 1

Privacy risk management – by design

I’ve discussed the Privacy by Design principle before, in the Inside Internal Control newsletter. In case you don’t know, PbD is an approach developed by Dr. Ann Cavoukian, the Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, which proactively embeds privacy protection by default in the design of an organization’s practices and products.

Colin Braithwaite

Read more
Imagen 1

Employment law update – Learn the latest!

This year’s Ontario Employment Law Conference co-sponsored by First Reference and Stringer Brisbin Humphrey on June 2, 2010, will touch on several topics of importance to employers. The first topic on the Agenda will provide employers with guidance on a significant court decision and changes in court procedures affecting the termination process. Specifically it should help employers minimize claims arising from the termination process.

Marie-Yosie Saint-Cyr, LL.B. Managing Editor

Read more